First Mutual Bank Headquarters

605 Washington Blvd, Belpre, OH 45714
(740) 423-9504

  • Monday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Tuesday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Wednesday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Thursday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Friday: 9:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: Closed
Headshot of Tammy Belcher
Tammy Belcher
Tammy Belcher | President

Phone: (740) 423-9504 ext. 6422
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Tammy Belcher is the President of First Mutual Bank.  She represents First Mutual Bank throughout the region and has ultimate responsibility for the sales, operations and financial performance of the bank.

Tammy has strong regional roots and extensive experience in banking. Most recently, Tammy was Vice President, Risk and Compliance Officer at First Mutual Bank, assuming this position in January 2018 when Belpre Savings Bank and Doolin Security Savings Bank merged to form First Mutual Bank. In this role, she was responsible for providing regulatory guidance to bank employees and the board of directors, and maintaining best practices for risk management across all lines of business. Tammy has held other roles of increasing responsibility for First Mutual Bank and Legg-Mason, including experience in operations, sales, lending compliance and marketing.
Belcher holds a bachelor’s degree in business administration from Marshall University. She also completed the American Bankers Association Graduate School of Compliance Management.
Headshot of Catherine Barker
Catherine Barker
VP, Lending Operations Officer
Catherine Barker | VP, Lending Operations Officer

NMLS# 1387033

Phone: (740) 423-9504 ext. 6421
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Cathy is Vice President, Lending Operations Officer at First Mutual Bank. In this role, Cathy oversees the daily operations of the lending department, as well as working directly with customers to help them choose the loan products that best meet their needs. She has more than 29 years of experience in the financial services industry, with extensive experience in mortgage and consumer lending.

Cathy joined Belpre Savings Bank in 2015 as Vice President, Lending Operations Officer, assuming her current role at First Mutual Bank in January 2018. Previously Cathy held various positions of increasing responsibility at First Neighborhood Bank, including Assistant Vice President of Lending Operations.
She has received advanced training through a number of financial services industry courses and seminars.
Headshot of Faith Browning
Faith Browning
Lending Specialist
Faith Browning | Lending Specialist

Phone: 740-423-9504 Ext. 6425
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Alisha Carmichael
Alisha Carmichael
Loan Processor
Alisha Carmichael | Loan Processor

Phone: (740) 423-9504 Ext. 6408
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Bruce Cowdery
Bruce Cowdery
Assistant Operations Officer
Bruce Cowdery | Assistant Operations Officer

Phone: (740) 423-9504 ext. 6423
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Sue Fleak
Sue Fleak
Systems Support Specialist
Sue Fleak | Systems Support Specialist

Phone: (740) 423-9504 Ext. 7401
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Liz McGill-Bleakley
Liz McGill-Bleakley
Loan Officer
Liz McGill-Bleakley | Loan Officer

NMLS# 537223

Phone: 740-423-9504 Ext. 5958
Mobile:(304) 588-6400
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Shawn Sandy
Shawn Sandy
VP, Commercial Lending
Shawn Sandy | VP, Commercial Lending

NMLS# 1520127

Phone: (740) 423-9504 Ext. 6420
Fax: (740) 423-6262

Headshot of Mary Youmans
Mary Youmans
Lending Specialist
Mary Youmans | Lending Specialist

NMLS# 1622740

Phone: (304) 422-1212
Fax: (304) 422-2511

Mary Youmans is a Lending Specialist with First Mutual Bank. She enjoys working with customers to help them choose the right mortgage or loan for their needs so they can realize the dream of home and auto ownership. She is a notary public and has received extensive Individual Retirement Account (IRA) training. She began her financial services career with West Virginia Central Credit Union as a teller before being promoted to Loan Officer in 2014. In the community, she is active with the March of Dimes and served as a team leader one year, with her team raising more than $100,000 for the organization.