Management Team

Headshot of Robert Doyle
Robert Doyle
President & CEO
Robert Doyle | President & CEO
Robert is the President and CEO of First Mutual Bank. Robert holds responsibility for all bank operations, policy and procedures to deliver exceptional products and services to customers, enhance the bank’s commitment to the communities it serves, and sustain a safe, sound institution.
 
Previously, Robert was President and CEO of Doolin Security Savings Bank, from January 2014 until assuming his current role in January 2018 when Doolin and Belpre Savings Bank merged to form First Mutual Bank. Prior to Doolin, he was Vice President of Collections for WesBanco Bank, where he oversaw a team of 24 who worked to reduce delinquency, lower charge offs and increase recovery on a loan portfolio valued at $ 1.2 billion. He also held other senior managerial level positions throughout his career which focused on debt portfolio acquisition and servicing.    
 
Robert received a Master of Business Administration from Waynesburg College and a bachelor’s degree in finance from West Virginia University. He previously served on the board of the Pennsylvania Association of Credit Management.
Headshot of Catherine Barker
Catherine Barker
VP, Lending Operations Officer
Catherine Barker | VP, Lending Operations Officer
Cathy is Vice President, Lending Operations Officer at First Mutual Bank. In this role, Cathy oversees the daily operations of the lending department, as well as working directly with customers to help them choose the loan products that best meet their needs. She has more than 29 years of experience in the financial services industry, with extensive experience in mortgage and consumer lending.

Cathy joined Belpre Savings Bank in 2015 as Vice President, Lending Operations Officer, assuming her current role at First Mutual Bank in January 2018. Previously Cathy held various positions of increasing responsibility at First Neighborhood Bank, including Assistant Vice President of Lending Operations.
 
She has received advanced training through a number of financial services industry courses and seminars.
Headshot of Tammy Belcher
Tammy Belcher
VP, Risk and Compliance Officer
Tammy Belcher | VP, Risk and Compliance Officer
Tammy is Vice President, Risk and Compliance Officer at First Mutual Bank. In this role, Tammy is responsible for providing regulatory guidance to bank employees and the board of directors, and maintaining best practices for risk management across all lines of business. She has extensive experience in deposit operations, lending compliance and marketing.
 
Previously, Tammy held the same position with Belpre Savings Bank, assuming her current role in January 2018 when Doolin Security Savings Bank and Belpre merged to form First Mutual Bank. Previously, she was Assistant Operations Manager at Belpre from 2004-2016.
 
Tammy received a bachelor’s degree in business administration from Marshall University. She also completed the American Bankers Association Graduate School of Compliance Management.
Headshot of Michael P. Eddy
Michael P. Eddy
VP, Chief Financial Officer
Michael P. Eddy | VP, Chief Financial Officer
Mike is Vice President, Chief Financial Officer at First Mutual Bank. As Chief Financial Officer, Mike oversees all financial affairs, including accounting and reporting, as well as investing and interest rate risk. He has extensive experience with accounting, operations and the Bank Secrecy Act.
 
Mike joined Belpre Savings Bank in 2000 as Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, assuming his current role in January 2018 when Belpre Savings Bank merged with Doolin Security Savings Bank to form First Mutual Bank.
 
He received a bachelor’s degree in accounting from Fairmont State College (now Fairmont State University).
Headshot of Debra Thomas
Debra Thomas
VP, Deposit Operations Officer
Debra Thomas | VP, Deposit Operations Officer
Debbie is Vice President, Deposit Operations Officer at First Mutual Bank. In this role, she helps oversee the day-to-day operations of the deposit area of the bank, as well as supporting the teller line and working directly with customers. Debbie has extensive experience in the financial services industry, starting as a teller at First Mutual Bank’s predecessor Doolin Security Savings Bank in 1984. She was steadily promoted to positions of greater responsibility and leadership, including most recently Compliance Officer.
 
Debbie attended West Virginia Northern Community College and has received advanced training through a number of financial services industry courses and seminars. She previously served as the Treasurer of the Tyler Consolidated High School Band Boosters and Treasurer of the American Red Cross–Wetzel County Chapter for 15 years.
Young woman counting banknotes after withdrawing cash from an ATM

Find a Location or
ATM Near You